DM Speaks:
I understand you can argue the post but in the end the group fled and was NOT able to defeat Desicus. Even the paladin has given up hope and decided to leave the Sea Dogs. Desicus will continue his bidding with Beluiri and maybe at some time a group which is brave and strong enough will tackle this challenge which the Sea Dogs abandoned and couldn't accomplish.
I do believe a great deal of the failure was due to the "messages" Desicus sent to each of you (except 1) which led to uncertainty. You may say "no", but the reality is bringing any question into a difficult situation is always bad! Desicus has proven his strength and laughs at EVERY MEMBER of the Sea Dogs.
Unfortunately, with you assault upon him will he bring the offensive to you without question! He is a demonic human who can never be trusted, and he would love to kill you all for fun (and destroy more temples and churches).
DM Speaks:
This situation will be remembered as one of the most treacherous moments with regards to actual player characters acting upon or against one another for their personal survival or benefit. Crazy. I look forward to tomorrow to clear the air and talk about the game and characters moving forward. I DON'T mean "clear the air" with regards to any animosity amongst players but simple allowing us all to sit down and really discuss it. It will be good. I have much to say as well and questions I'd like to ask.