DM Speaks:
You found a Genie Lamp!
First, remember that wishes are NOT a guarantee. There is a % for each depending on how possible they are to happen. You could wish Magister Arbados or Lord Garou to be dead but the % may be 1% if that. Wishes are great but very tricky. The genies that grant these wishes are always looking for ways to grant them but also satisfy their desire to alter them to their fun and satisfaction. Don't get me wrong, getting wishes is phenomenal but just be smart as the DM, ah I meant the Genie within, is always looking for a way to alter your desire!
You have still not destroyed Palasha the Sea Crone! I'm surprised at how difficult she has been to take down. Unfortunately, this leads me to emphasize her and make her more as being a potential long-term enemy. Thank you!
Taladel speaks:
I think the lamp should be given to the captain for his consideration. Imagine his feelings if he was told we took it upon ourselves to make wishes without his knowledge...He may choose to give it to us, but he should be made aware before any wishes are made!
It is the only item that may satisfy him. And we should come to him with something of value..after the last time.